In the plant room, everything appears to be working. The fan runs, the controls respond and air is moving through the main system. Upstairs, however, one room remains uncomfortable. Turning the system up seems an obvious response, until another area becomes noisy or draughty and the original concern is still not properly understood.
Between the fan and the people it serves lies a distribution system. Its routes, joints, branches, controls and terminals all matter. Looking only at the plant can miss what happens along that route. The question for a building manager is whether the intended air reaches the intended place under the conditions in which the room is used.
Tony Anderson of the Commissioning Specialists Association raised the importance of ductwork leakage testing in “Challenging the status quo”, published in November 2024. His article argued for greater attention to installation quality and verification. The enduring lesson is to examine delivered performance rather than assume it from a running fan. His proposals for wider testing should not be confused with a statement of current law.
Follow the air through the building
For a client, a useful starting point is a drawing that connects the occupied room to its serving system. Where does supply air arrive, where is air extracted and which other spaces share the arrangement? The aim is to understand the route before deciding where to investigate it.
That can be less straightforward than the drawing suggests. Commercial premises may have undergone several fit-outs, with room names and layouts changing while central plant remains in place. A current survey should establish which information is reliable and where the installation needs further identification. An unverified drawing is a starting point, not a finding.
The route also helps clarify responsibilities. The landlord may control the central plant, a tenant may have commissioned an internal alteration and another contractor may maintain local equipment. If the investigation stops at those contractual boundaries, the physical route can remain unexplained. Someone needs to coordinate the evidence across the relevant parts of the system.
Green Air Monitoring’s investigation of indoor environmental concerns can help establish what is happening in the affected space. Engineering examination of the distribution system may then be required. The value comes from connecting the room evidence with the appropriate technical investigation, rather than asking either discipline to infer everything alone.
What duct leakage means in practice
Air can pass through unintended openings in ductwork when there is a pressure difference across them. In a supply duct operating above the surrounding pressure, leakage can allow air to escape before reaching the intended outlet. In an extract section operating below its surroundings, leakage can draw air into the duct along the route.
The direction therefore depends on local conditions. It is not accurate to describe every leak as supply air escaping or contaminated extract air entering a room. The location, pressure relationship and system arrangement determine the significance. A useful investigation identifies those details rather than using the word leakage as a complete explanation.
An extract fan can move air that has entered through unintended openings as well as air collected at the intended extract points. A supply fan can move a volume that does not all arrive at the terminals under examination. These possibilities help explain why a plant reading alone cannot settle a question about a particular room.
They do not prove that leakage caused the complaint. Restrictions, control arrangements, balancing, changed room use and measurement limitations may also need consideration. The purpose of following the air route is to distinguish these possibilities, so that remedial work addresses an identified problem rather than the most convenient theory.
Three different meanings of “airtight”
Building airtightness, ductwork airtightness and room ventilation performance are related but distinct. A building-envelope test examines leakage through the fabric under a defined test arrangement. A ductwork leakage test concerns the integrity of a specified duct section. Neither automatically establishes the outdoor-air provision experienced by occupants during normal use.
This distinction matters during retrofit. Improving the building fabric does not demonstrate that the ventilation distribution system is sound. Equally, a satisfactory duct test does not establish that the building’s ventilation strategy suits a new layout or pattern of occupancy. The commissioning and assessment plan should identify which questions each test will answer.
There is a further distinction between airtightness and cleanliness. A duct can be internally clean while having an integrity issue, or sufficiently airtight while requiring hygiene attention. The evidence and methods differ. Combining the terms in a general statement that the ventilation has been checked can conceal what was actually examined.
For the facilities manager, the practical remedy is precise language. Ask which system or component was tested, under which method, against which requirement and for what purpose. A clear answer avoids buying one kind of evidence and later discovering that the unresolved concern needed another.
Ask which requirement applies to this system
BESA publishes DW/143 for ductwork air leakage testing and DW/144 for sheet-metal ductwork. Their roles should be identified in the project specification, together with the applicable requirements for the particular system. The presence of a reference on a quotation does not explain the complete testing scope.
A leakage class belongs to a technical specification and test context. It should not be selected by copying an example from another building or assuming that a more demanding classification always answers the client’s problem. The responsible designer or specialist should explain the selection and its implications for the installation.
The original article proposed changes to established practice. That is a useful contribution to an industry discussion, but a proposal is not evidence that every existing system must now be upgraded or pressure-tested in the same way. The client’s requirements need to be established from the current project, applicable rules and competent technical advice.
Across the UK, building regulations are administered through different national arrangements. An old reference to an English Approved Document should not become a blanket instruction for a Scottish, Welsh or Northern Irish project. A clear brief identifies the jurisdiction and project circumstances without asking a general blog to serve as the compliance specification.
Test at a stage when findings can be acted on
If a project requires ductwork leakage testing, the construction programme should allow for it while the relevant sections remain accessible. Discovering an issue after finishes or insulation restrict access can complicate the remedial work. Testing needs to be planned as part of delivery, rather than appended to the end as a paperwork exercise.
CIBSE’s overview of the revised air-distribution commissioning guidance highlights early consideration of access and ductwork leakage testing before ceilings or insulation are installed. The client’s useful question is whether the project programme gives the relevant specialists the opportunity to inspect, test and resolve findings at the appropriate stage.
Define the boundaries of each test section and preserve them in the record. Where work is completed in stages, the next team needs to know which parts have been demonstrated and which remain outstanding. A series of individual test sheets should build into an understandable account of the installed system.
Alterations after a test also need consideration. A successful result relates to the tested arrangement, not automatically to every later change. The responsible specialist should decide what further verification is needed when the installation is modified. The change record should make it possible to trace that decision.
A shortfall is a clue, not yet a diagnosis
Suppose a team compares a main-system airflow with readings at a group of terminals and finds a difference. It may be tempting to label the difference as leakage. Before doing so, the investigation needs to establish whether the measurements cover the same system boundary, operating state and relevant air paths.
Measurement uncertainty and method differences also matter. A comparison assembled from readings taken at different times or under different control demands may be misleading. The person interpreting it should explain whether the data are suitable for the proposed conclusion and what further work would strengthen it.
A dedicated leakage test answers a defined integrity question. An operational airflow investigation examines performance in use. They can support one another, but neither should be described as the other. A useful report shows how each result contributes to the explanation rather than allowing several different tests to share a single vague conclusion.
For occupants, the ultimate concern is the room. Keep that concern in view while investigating the ductwork. If an integrity issue is found and repaired, the affected space still needs the relevant performance checks. Resolving one fault is valuable, but it should not silently close an investigation whose original question remains unanswered.
Why simply increasing fan output can miss the point
A higher fan setting may change the measured flow, but it does not explain why a shortfall existed. If the problem lies in distribution, an indiscriminate increase can change conditions in areas that were not part of the complaint. Any adjustment should be made by the responsible specialist with the wider system in view.
Energy consequences also deserve careful treatment. Duct leakage can create avoidable demand, but the actual effect depends on the system and its controls. The original article’s general argument for reducing waste should not become a promise of a particular saving for an unassessed property. That requires a defined baseline and suitable operational evidence.
The same caution applies to a percentage change in fan speed. Simplified fan relationships can be useful in engineering analysis under the appropriate assumptions, but they are not a ready-made prediction of electrical consumption in every installed system. A client-facing investigation should report the relevant measured or properly assessed outcome.
The better question is whether the system is delivering its intended service efficiently and consistently. That invites a competent review of the cause, the remedy and the resulting performance. It also avoids a cycle in which successive complaints lead to successive adjustments, while the original distribution issue remains hidden.
Consider a hypothetical Leeds office undergoing a tenant fit-out. The central plant is retained, but part of an open floor becomes several enclosed rooms. After occupation, one room attracts repeated comments about stuffiness. The project file contains a satisfactory test result for part of the original installation.
That result is relevant history, but the investigation needs to establish what changed. Which branches and terminals now serve the room? Were alterations included in the testing and commissioning scope? Were the design assumptions updated for the new use? A base-build record cannot answer those questions simply because it carries the building’s address.
If further work identifies a duct integrity problem, the contractor should address it against the agreed specification. If the evidence instead points to balancing or control operation, the remedy will differ. The scenario illustrates the value of an open investigation: several plausible explanations can produce a similar occupant description.
Once the work is complete, verify the relevant performance and record the final arrangement. The landlord and tenant should each receive the information needed for their responsibilities. Otherwise, the next fit-out begins with the same uncertainty about where one system ends and another party’s evidence begins.
Keep room air quality in the assessment
An air-distribution investigation and an indoor environmental assessment can meet at the occupied room. The engineering work establishes relevant system behaviour; the environmental assessment examines selected conditions and the context in which people report a concern. Their conclusions should be connected without treating them as interchangeable.
Our indoor air quality testing can help define conditions during an appropriate period of use. The scope should match the complaint and the question remaining after the engineering review. A quiet-room result is not a complete answer to a problem reported only during long, heavily occupied sessions.
Avoid assuming that every concern downstream of a ductwork fault has the same cause. An odour may require a separate source or pathway investigation; a thermal complaint may involve local conditions. Documenting the system fault is an important finding, but the assessment should follow each material concern through to the evidence that addresses it.
This approach is particularly useful where several contractors are involved. Agree how findings will be shared and what would count as satisfactory resolution. The client should receive a coherent account of the building, not several individually correct reports that leave the relationship between them unexplained.
Leave a route that the next team can follow
The final record should identify what was tested, what was found, what changed and which outcome was verified. Keep current system drawings and location references with the results. Where limitations remain, assign the next action and explain its significance rather than burying it in a general disclaimer.
For ongoing building management, preserve the difference between routine review and a specific integrity investigation. There is no benefit in commissioning the same test repeatedly without a reason, just as there is little value in ignoring a documented issue because the fan still operates. Future decisions should be informed by the system’s history and relevant changes.
A wider building health assessment can help frame the indoor environmental questions where the property has several concerns or a major change of use. It should complement the work of the relevant engineering specialists, with clear responsibilities for any design, repair or controls intervention.
The sound of a running fan is easy to recognise. The evidence that air reaches the right place takes more work. By following the distribution route, defining the test and checking the occupied result, building teams can replace assumptions with an explanation they can act on. That is the point at which ventilation becomes more than plant that appears to be running.